Despite the fact that we very nearly wanted nothing to do with each other after that first game, we couldn't help but recognize that Innovation was pretty amazing. So despite that miserable first experience, we both ended up getting our own copies once we got home from Gencon. We've just never actually played it with each other since.
Innovation is a civilization themed tableau building game. It was published in 2010 by Asmadi, and was designed by Carl Chudyk. There is also an Iello edition in the US now, which has better artwork than the Asmadi edition. I'm not 100% sure how two publishers can be releasing the same game in the same region.
